What the Latest Apple Ruling Means for App Developers: A Breakdown of the New Guidelines and Apple’s Legal Challenges
- Giselle Pagliari
- May 2
- 5 min read
In recent weeks, the tech world has been abuzz with news surrounding Apple’s legal battle with Epic Games. A U.S. court ruling has forced Apple to take significant steps to open up its App Store to more competition, particularly regarding in-app payment options. This ruling, stemming from a case Epic Games filed back in 2020, has had profound implications for app developers, particularly those operating within the United States.
At Devusol, we know that navigating these changing regulations is essential for app developers who want to stay competitive and compliant. Let’s break down the latest developments and what they mean for the future of app development, especially in light of Apple’s recent communication with developers.
The Court Ruling: A Game-Changer for Apple’s App Store
Apple’s strict control over the App Store and its commission fees has been a point of contention for several years. Epic Games, the creator of the hugely popular game Fortnite, took Apple to court over these issues, arguing that Apple’s App Store policies were anti-competitive and violated antitrust laws.
In 2021, a U.S. District Court judge, Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers, ruled in favor of Epic Games, issuing an injunction that required Apple to allow developers to direct users to external payment options, avoiding the Apple App Store’s 30% commission. This ruling effectively opened the door for alternative payment methods outside the App Store ecosystem.
Fast forward to 2024, Apple failed to convince the U.S. Supreme Court to overturn the injunction, which means the new rules are in effect. However, the recent ruling on May 1, 2025, marks a new chapter in this ongoing legal saga, with the judge accusing Apple of "willful" violations of the court’s original order.
Key Points from the Ruling: What Apple Must Do
According to Judge Gonzalez Rogers, Apple has not complied with her previous injunction in multiple ways. The key violations include:
Charging a 27% Fee: Apple imposed a 27% fee on app developers when users make purchases outside the App Store. This is considered an attempt to circumvent the court order, which aimed to allow more flexibility in payment methods.
Misleading Consumers: The court also found that Apple used “scare screens,” pop-up warnings that discouraged users from using third-party payment options. These warnings were designed to mislead users about the safety and reliability of non-Apple payment systems.
Lack of Transparency: The court found that Apple had not been transparent about its internal decision-making process and had misled the court during legal proceedings.
As a result, the judge referred Apple to federal prosecutors for potential criminal contempt charges. While this is a severe development, it highlights the seriousness with which courts are approaching Apple's behavior and its impact on the app development ecosystem.
What Does This Mean for App Developers?
For app developers, especially those who rely heavily on in-app purchases, this ruling is a critical development. Here’s what the ruling means for developers moving forward:
More Payment Flexibility: Developers will now have the ability to integrate alternative payment systems into their apps. This opens up new opportunities for reducing reliance on Apple’s in-app purchase system, which has a hefty 30% commission. With the new ruling, app developers have a chance to recapture some of that revenue.
New Apple App Review Guidelines: In response to this court ruling, Apple updated its App Review Guidelines. According to Apple’s latest email to developers, changes have been made specifically for the U.S. App Store storefront:
Developers are not prohibited from including buttons, external links, or other calls to action that allow users to browse NFT collections owned by others.
There is no requirement for an External Link Account entitlement for apps on the U.S. storefront to include buttons or external links. This removes previous limitations on how developers could point users to external platforms for purchases.
The prohibition on encouraging users to use purchasing methods other than in-app purchase does not apply to U.S.-based apps, which means developers have more freedom in directing users to external payment options.
Financial Impact: The ruling could significantly impact the financial dynamics of the App Store. While developers will gain more control over payment options, Apple may still charge a fee on transactions that occur outside its App Store ecosystem. It will be important for developers to consider these fees and how they affect their overall business models.
Transparency and Trust: The ruling underscores the need for greater transparency within the app ecosystem. Developers may find themselves subject to more scrutiny, and it will be essential to maintain open lines of communication with their users, particularly when directing them to external payment options.
Apple’s Response: What Happens Next?
Apple, unsurprisingly, disagrees with the court’s ruling and intends to appeal the decision. The company has stated that it will seek a review from the 9th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals and may request the suspension of the injunction while it pursues its challenge.
Despite this, the implications of the ruling are clear for developers. Even if Apple is able to delay or overturn some parts of the ruling, the legal landscape surrounding app store commissions and payment systems is changing rapidly. App developers will need to stay informed and be prepared for any adjustments Apple may make in its policies moving forward.
What Should Developers Do?
As the landscape shifts, it’s essential for app developers to:
Review the App Store Guidelines: With these changes in mind, developers should revisit the latest App Store guidelines and ensure they’re in compliance with the updated policies.
Explore Alternative Payment Methods: If your app is one of the many that rely on in-app purchases, now is a good time to explore alternative payment methods and ensure your app is set up to integrate them smoothly.
Prepare for Potential Changes: Keep a close eye on Apple’s ongoing legal challenges and stay updated on any new rulings or modifications to the App Store guidelines.
Conclusion: A New Era for App Development
The recent ruling in the Epic Games case represents a landmark moment for app developers. With Apple now required to allow more flexibility in payment options and reduce its control over transactions, the future of the app ecosystem could see dramatic shifts. While it’s still uncertain how this will all play out, developers need to stay agile, informed, and ready to adapt to the evolving regulatory landscape.
At Devusol, we are committed to helping our clients navigate these changes. Whether you’re looking to develop a new mobile app, optimize your current solutions with AI, or integrate new payment systems, our team is here to provide expert guidance and support.
The app development world is evolving, and now is the time to ensure your business is ready for whatever comes next.
Comments